Wrapping Paper Garbage Bin All wrapping paper at this point in time must be placed in the garbage can. Metallic Paper Is Not Recyclable Wrapping paper that is shiny, or contains foil and metallic pieces, cannot be recycled due to the mix of materials. No Tissue Paper Tissue paper is made out of recycled paper fibers that are too short to recycle. Find out what to do with tissue paper. Ways to Reduce Choose Recycled Paper Instead of using paper made with virgin fibers, wrap your gifts in newspaper or brown paper with 100 percent recycled content. Newspaper Wrapping Wrap your gifts in newspaper instead of metallic wrapping paper. This reduces waste because you’re reusing the newspaper and not purchasing anything that’s non-recyclable. Ways to Reuse Save for Next Year Wrapping paper in good condition can be folded neatly and stored for reuse at your next celebration or holiday. Did You Know? Gift Wrapping Waste How much gift wrapping waste do Americans generate on a yearly basis? About two pounds per person, or 40 million pounds in total, which includes paper products used to wrap, package and decorate gifts. 38 million miles of ribbon are discarded per year, which is enough to wrap around the Earth.